The Thing: John Carpenter’s Journey from Flop to Masterpiece

Brock Swinson
3 min readOct 16, 2024

--

In 1982, John Carpenter was riding high on the success of his low-budget horror hits. Then came “The Thing” — a $3M sci-fi thriller that would challenge everything he knew about filmmaking and temporarily derail his career. Here’s how this initially maligned project became a cult classic:

From B-movie Director to Visionary

  • Carpenter’s early career was defined by low-budget successes like “Halloween” (1978)
  • Universal Studios offered him $3M to remake the 1951 sci-fi classic “The Thing from Another World”

“I never thought of myself as anything but a genre director.” — John Carpenter

Assembling a Dream Team

Carpenter knew he needed top talent to bring his vision to life:

  • Rob Bottin, a 22-year-old effects prodigy, was hired to create the film’s groundbreaking practical effects
  • The cast, led by Kurt Russell, brought gravitas to the paranoid Antarctic setting

“Rob Bottin was a genius. He brought the creature to life.” — John Carpenter

A Grueling Production

The shoot was as challenging as the story itself:

  • Filmed in remote locations in Alaska and British Columbia
  • Temperatures dropped to 30 degrees below zero
  • The harsh conditions mirrored the film’s isolated, tense atmosphere

Embrace adversity — it can fuel your creative fire.

A Chilly Reception

Despite the team’s efforts, “The Thing” landed with a thud:

  • Released in June 1982, it was overshadowed by the more optimistic “E.T.”
  • Critics panned its bleak tone and graphic violence
  • The film grossed only $19.6M domestically, barely covering costs

“It was hated. Hated by fans. Hated by critics.” — John Carpenter

Career Consequences

The film’s failure had immediate repercussions:

  • Carpenter’s Hollywood trajectory was derailed
  • He returned to lower-budget productions
  • The experience left him questioning his artistic choices

Failure is not the end — it’s often the beginning of something greater.

The Slow Burn of Success

Like its shape-shifting monster, “The Thing” refused to die:

  • Home video releases in the late ’80s and ’90s found a new audience
  • Critics began to reassess the film’s merits
  • Today, it’s considered Carpenter’s masterpiece and a landmark of sci-fi horror

“People caught up with it years later.” — John Carpenter

Lessons from “The Thing”:

  1. Trust your vision, even when others don’t see it
  2. Surround yourself with talented collaborators
  3. Don’t fear pushing boundaries — it might alienate some but inspire many
  4. Initial failure doesn’t define a work’s ultimate value
  5. Persistence and belief in your art can outlast initial setbacks

“It’s the best thing I’ve ever done.” — John Carpenter

John Carpenter’s journey with “The Thing” teaches us that true innovation often faces initial resistance. What seems like a career-ending failure can become your most celebrated work.

We’re channeling John Carpenter’s resilient mindset. We call it the Screenwriter’s Battering Ram Here’s a free training to learn how to weather any storm in your writing career:

https://www.scriptmastermind.com/training

--

--

Brock Swinson
Brock Swinson

Written by Brock Swinson

I Help Creatives Get Their Most Ambitious Work into the World... https://www.brockswinson.com/home

No responses yet